Review Process

JIG  strictly adheres to the professional ethics standards of science and technology journal, and handles manuscripts fairly. Adopting double anonymous peer review mechanism, where editors do not disclose the names and affiliations of authors and reviewers. The review cycle is generally within 2 months, and the period from submission to publication is generally around 6 months. The review results and comments are summarized by the editor of this journal and promptly notified to the authors.

In Review: The manuscript has been assigned to the reviewing experts, who are currently reviewing it, including initial and final reviews. The system has not subdivided this status.

Initial review review review: Generally, each manuscript is sent to two external review experts for review. However, due to the fact that each reviewer has their own work, the feedback time may not be consistent. This status indicates that the manuscript has already received one external review opinion (which cannot be viewed at this time).

Preliminary review has been reviewed: Refers to 2-3 external review comments being returned to the editorial department, awaiting submission for final review (comments cannot be viewed at this time).

Final review has been reviewed: The final review comments have been returned to the editorial department. As they are all anonymous reviewers, the author cannot view the review comments at this time. After the review comments are processed by the editor, they will be provided to the author for review, and the author will be notified via email.